<?xml version='1.0' encoding='utf-8'?>
<subtitle article="gle" title_number="4" subtitle_number="3" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-301" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <level label="a">
      <text>In this subtitle the following words have the meanings indicated.</text>
    </level>
    <level label="b">
      <text>“Injunctive relief” means:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>a permanent injunction;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>a temporary injunction; or</text>
      </level>
      <level label="3">
        <text>a temporary restraining order.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="c">
      <text>“Labor dispute” includes any controversy, regardless of whether the disputants stand in the proximate relation of employee or employer, concerning:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>terms or conditions of employment;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>employment relations;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="3">
        <text>the association or representation of persons in negotiating, setting, maintaining, or changing terms or conditions of employment; or</text>
      </level>
      <level label="4">
        <text>any other controversy arising out of the respective interests of employee or employer.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="d">
      <text>“Person participating or interested in a labor dispute” means a person against whom relief is sought if the person:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>is engaged in the industry, craft, trade, or occupation in which the dispute occurs; or</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>is an agent, member, or officer of an association of employees or employers engaged in the industry, craft, trade, or occupation in which the dispute occurs.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-302" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <level label="a">
      <text>The General Assembly finds that:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>governmental authority has allowed and encouraged employers to organize in corporate and other forms of capital control; and</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>in dealing with these employers, an individual worker who is not represented by an organization is helpless to exercise liberty of contract or to protect personal freedom of labor and, thus, to obtain acceptable terms and conditions of employment.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="b">
      <text>The policy of the State is that:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>negotiation of terms and conditions of employment should result from voluntary agreement between employees and employer; and</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>therefore, each individual worker must be:</text>
        <level label="i">
          <text>fully free to associate, organize, and designate a representative, as the worker chooses, for negotiation of terms and conditions of employment; and</text>
        </level>
        <level label="ii">
          <text>free from coercion, interference, or restraint by an employer or an agent of an employer in:</text>
          <level label="1">
            <text>designation of a representative;</text>
          </level>
          <level label="2">
            <text>self-organization; and</text>
          </level>
          <level label="3">
            <text>other concerted activity for the purpose of collective bargaining or other mutual aid or protection.</text>
          </level>
        </level>
      </level>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-303" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <text>This subtitle shall be interpreted and applied in accordance with the policy stated in § 4-302 of this subtitle.</text>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-304" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <level label="a">
      <text>In this section, “promise” means any undertaking, whether express or implied or oral or written.</text>
    </level>
    <level label="b">
      <text>A promise made between an employee or prospective employee and an employer, prospective employer, or any other individual, association, company, corporation, or firm is against the policy of the State if the promise requires either party:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>to join or remain a member of an employer or labor organization;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>not to join or not to remain a member of an employer or labor organization; or</text>
      </level>
      <level label="3">
        <text>to withdraw from an employment relation if the party joins or remains a member of an employer or labor organization.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="c">
      <text>A court may not grant, on the basis of a promise described in this section, any relief against:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>a party to the promise; or</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>another person who, without the act or threat of fraud or violence, advises, induces, or urges a party to disregard the promise.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-307" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <text>A court does not have jurisdiction to grant injunctive relief that specifically or generally:</text>
    <level label="1">
      <text>prohibits a person from ceasing or refusing to perform work or to remain in a relation of employment, regardless of a promise to do the work or to remain in the relation;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="2">
      <text>prohibits a person from becoming or remaining a member of an employer organization or labor organization, regardless of a promise described in § 4–304 of this subtitle;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="3">
      <text>prohibits a person from paying or giving to, or withholding from, another person any thing of value, including money or strike or unemployment benefits or insurance;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="4">
      <text>prohibits a person from helping, by lawful means, another person to bring or defend against an action in a court of any state or the United States;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="5">
      <text>prohibits a person from publicizing or obtaining or communicating information about the existence of or a fact involved in a labor dispute by any method that does not involve the act or threat of a breach of the peace, fraud, or violence, including:</text>
      <level label="i">
        <text>advertising;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="ii">
        <text>speaking; and</text>
      </level>
      <level label="iii">
        <text>patrolling, with intimidation or coercion, a public street or other place where a person lawfully may be;</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="6">
      <text>prohibits a person from ceasing:</text>
      <level label="i">
        <text>to patronize another person; or</text>
      </level>
      <level label="ii">
        <text>to employ another person;</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="7">
      <text>prohibits a person from assembling peaceably to do or to organize an act listed in items (1) through (6) of this section;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="8">
      <text>prohibits a person from advising or giving another person notice of an intent to do an act listed in items (1) through (7) of this section;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="9">
      <text>prohibits a person from agreeing with another person to do or not to do an act listed in items (1) through (8) of this section;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="10">
      <text>prohibits a person from advising, inducing, or urging another person, without the act or threat of fraud or violence, to do an act listed in items (1) through (9) of this section, regardless of a promise described in § 4–304 of this subtitle; or</text>
    </level>
    <level label="11">
      <text>on the ground that the persons are engaged in an unlawful conspiracy, prohibits a person from doing an act listed in items (1) through (10) of this section in concert with another person.</text>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-310" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <text>A case shall be held to involve or grow out of a labor dispute when the case involves:</text>
    <level label="1">
      <text>persons who are engaged in a single industry, trade, craft, or occupation, employees of the same employer, or members of the same or an affiliated organization of employees or employers, regardless of whether the dispute is between:</text>
      <level label="i">
        <text>1 or more employees or associations of employees and 1 or more employers or associations of employers;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="ii">
        <text>1 or more employees or associations of employees and 1 or more employees or associations of employees; or</text>
      </level>
      <level label="iii">
        <text>1 or more employers or associations of employers and 1 or more employers or associations of employers; or</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="2">
      <text>a conflicting or competing interest in a labor dispute of a person participating or interested in the labor dispute.</text>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-311" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <text>The General Assembly finds that a procedure that allows a plaintiff to obtain sweeping injunctive relief without giving to each defendant notice of and a hearing based wholly or partly on examination and cross-examination of witnesses in open court, rather than on affidavits alone, is peculiarly subject to abuse in later litigation because:</text>
    <level label="1">
      <text>injunctive relief necessarily alters, rather than maintains, the status quo;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="2">
      <text>determination of issues of veracity and of probability of fact from affidavits of the opposing parties that are contradictory and, under the circumstances, untrustworthy rather than from oral examination in open court is subject to grave error;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="3">
      <text>erroneous issuance of injunctive relief usually is irreparable to the defendant; and</text>
    </level>
    <level label="4">
      <text>delay incident to appeals frequently makes ultimate correction of error unavailing in a particular case.</text>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-312" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <text>This Part III of this subtitle shall be interpreted and applied in accordance with the policy stated in § 4-311 of this subtitle.</text>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-313" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <level label="a">
      <text>A court may not grant injunctive relief in a labor dispute:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>if the plaintiff has failed to comply with each obligation imposed by law that is involved in the labor dispute; or</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>except as provided in subsection (b) of this section, if the plaintiff has failed to make every reasonable effort to settle the labor dispute:</text>
        <level label="i">
          <text>by negotiation; or</text>
        </level>
        <level label="ii">
          <text>with the help of available dispute resolution mechanisms, governmental mediation, or voluntary arbitration.</text>
        </level>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="b">
      <text>If irreparable injury is threatened, a court may grant injunctive relief before another tribunal acts to settle the labor dispute.</text>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-314" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <text>In addition to any other limitation under this Part III of this subtitle, a court may not issue a temporary or permanent injunction in a case that involves or grows out of a labor dispute unless:</text>
    <level label="1">
      <text>each known person against whom relief is sought and each public officer who has a duty to protect the property of the plaintiff is given, in the manner that the court directs, personal notice that the court will hold a hearing on issuance of a temporary or permanent injunction;</text>
    </level>
    <level label="2">
      <text>at the hearing, the court takes, in open court, testimony offered against the temporary or permanent injunction and affords the opportunity for cross-examination; and</text>
    </level>
    <level label="3">
      <text>as a result of the hearing, the court finds that:</text>
      <level label="i">
        <text>an unlawful act:</text>
        <level label="1">
          <text>has been threatened and, unless restrained, will be committed; or</text>
        </level>
        <level label="2">
          <text>has been committed and, unless restrained, will be continued;</text>
        </level>
      </level>
      <level label="ii">
        <text>unless it grants the relief requested, the property of the plaintiff will be injured substantially and irreparably;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="iii">
        <text>greater injury will be inflicted on the plaintiff for each item of relief that the court denies than will be inflicted on the defendant if the court grants the item;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="iv">
        <text>it is not granting any item of relief for which a court lacks jurisdiction under § 4-307 of this subtitle;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="v">
        <text>the plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law; and</text>
      </level>
      <level label="vi">
        <text>each public officer who has a duty to protect the property of the plaintiff has failed or is unable to give adequate protection.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-315" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <level label="a">
      <text>If, in addition to meeting the requirements for an injunction under § 4-314 of this subtitle, a plaintiff alleges that, unless a temporary restraining order is issued before a court holds a hearing on issuance of other injunctive relief in a case that involves or grows out of a labor dispute, substantial and irreparable injury to the property of the plaintiff is unavoidable, the court may issue a temporary restraining order in accordance with this section.</text>
    </level>
    <level label="b">
      <level label="1">
        <text>The court shall pass a show cause order that gives each party whom the plaintiff seeks to have restrained a reasonable period of at least 48 hours in which to show cause why the court should not issue a temporary restraining order.</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>A show cause order shall be served on each party whom the plaintiff seeks to have restrained as provided in the show cause order.</text>
      </level>
      <level label="3">
        <text>On expiration of the period to show cause, the court may issue a temporary restraining order if on the basis of testimony or, in the discretion of the court, an affidavit, the court finds that issuance of a temporary injunction would be justified if a hearing were held.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="c">
      <level label="1">
        <text>A temporary restraining order issued under this section is effective for the period that the court sets but not more than 5 days.</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>If a hearing for a temporary injunction begins before the expiration of the period set under this subsection, the court may continue the temporary restraining order until the court decides whether to issue the temporary injunction.</text>
      </level>
      <level label="3">
        <text>Unless the court continues a temporary restraining order in accordance with paragraph (2) of this subsection, then on expiration of the period set under this subsection, the order is void and may not be renewed or extended.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-316" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <level label="a">
      <text>Before a court issues a temporary restraining order or temporary injunction in a case that involves or grows out of a labor dispute, the plaintiff shall post bond with the court.</text>
    </level>
    <level label="b">
      <level label="1">
        <text>Bond under this section shall be in an amount sufficient to compensate each person who is enjoined for any loss, expense, or damages that improvident or erroneous issuance of the temporary restraining order or temporary injunction causes.</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>The amount shall include reasonable counsel fees and other reasonable costs that a defendant incurs in defending against other injunctive relief in the same case if the court denies the injunctive relief.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="c">
      <text>Bond under this section signifies an agreement between the plaintiff and surety to submit to the jurisdiction of the court for the purpose of being liable on the bond.</text>
    </level>
    <level label="d">
      <text>This section does not prevent a party who has a claim on or under a bond from bringing an action to pursue an ordinary remedy in court.</text>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-317" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <level label="a">
      <text>A court may not grant injunctive relief in a case that involves or grows out of a labor dispute until the court makes and files, in the record of the case, findings of fact.</text>
    </level>
    <level label="b">
      <text>Injunctive relief in a case that involves or grows out of a labor dispute shall prohibit an act only if:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>the complaint in the labor case expressly complains of the specific act; and</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>the findings of fact expressly include the specific act.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="c">
      <text>Injunctive relief in a case that involves or grows out of a labor dispute is binding only on a person:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>who receives, by personal service or otherwise, actual notice of the injunctive relief; and</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>who is:</text>
        <level label="i">
          <text>a party to the case;</text>
        </level>
        <level label="ii">
          <text>an agent or employee of a party or lawyer who represents a party; or</text>
        </level>
        <level label="iii">
          <text>a person in active concert and participation with a party.</text>
        </level>
      </level>
    </level>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-318" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <text>A party may appeal to the Appellate Court of Maryland from the issuance or denial of a temporary injunction in a case that involves or grows out of a labor dispute.</text>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-321" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <text>An organization or officer or member of an organization participating or interested in a labor dispute has immunity from liability in accordance with § 5-414 of the Courts Article.</text>
  </section>
  <section article="gle" article_name="Labor and Employment" number="4-322" title_number="4" title_name="Bargaining Representatives; Labor Disputes" subtitle_number="3" subtitle_name="Injunctions">
    <level label="a">
      <text>A person who is charged with constructive criminal contempt for a violation of injunctive relief in a case that involves or grows out of a labor dispute is entitled:</text>
      <level label="1">
        <text>to pretrial release as provided for defendants in criminal cases;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>to notice of the accusation;</text>
      </level>
      <level label="3">
        <text>to a reasonable time to make a defense; and</text>
      </level>
      <level label="4">
        <text>except for an officer of the court who is charged with disobedience, misbehavior, or other misconduct in respect to process of the court, on demand, to a speedy and public trial by an impartial jury from the judicial district where the contempt is alleged to have been committed.</text>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="b">
      <level label="1">
        <text>Whenever the charge of constructive criminal contempt arises from an attack on the character or conduct of a judge, the defendant is entitled to recusal of the judge if the defendant files a demand for recusal before the hearing on the charge.</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>Whenever a defendant files a timely demand for recusal:</text>
        <level label="i">
          <text>the judge may not proceed further; and</text>
        </level>
        <level label="ii">
          <text>the presiding judge of the court shall designate another judge as a replacement.</text>
        </level>
      </level>
    </level>
    <level label="c">
      <level label="1">
        <text>A person who is guilty of constructive criminal contempt in a labor case is subject to a fine not exceeding $100 or imprisonment not exceeding 15 days or both.</text>
      </level>
      <level label="2">
        <text>A person who is imprisoned for failure to pay a fine imposed under this subsection shall be discharged:</text>
        <level label="i">
          <text>after 15 days; or</text>
        </level>
        <level label="ii">
          <text>if also imprisoned for a definite period, 15 days after the end of the period.</text>
        </level>
      </level>
    </level>
  </section>
</subtitle>